A lower monthly price doesn’t tell you what you’ll pay today, when the discount ends or what a move will take. So compare both options over the same stretch of time, and keep two totals: the cash you’ll pay, and the cost of the service you’ll actually use in that stretch.
Use this worksheet with your real renewal notice and a written quote from the other host. It’s useful even if you don’t move. Staying can be the better choice.
First, pick your comparison period
Choose a start date and an end date, such as the next 24 months. Use the same currency and the same number of sites for both options. Don’t compare a new-customer promotion with a renewal bill as if they were the same offer.
If the first term lasts three or four years, renewal doesn’t start in year two. Write down the actual renewal month. If a bill buys service past your end date, put the full payment in the cash column and note the unused future service separately.
Copy this worksheet and fill in both columns
Use the amounts from your invoices and quotes where you have them. If you don’t know a number, write “unknown”, not zero.
| What to record | Stay with your current host | Switch to another host |
|---|---|---|
| Start date, end date and currency | Your chosen dates and currency | The same dates and currency |
| Websites and resources | Your sites, storage and current needs | The same needs, including separate plans if you need them |
| Prepaid time left at the start | Months already paid for past your start date, and their end date | Usually none for a new host, unless you’ve already paid |
| First payment after the start date | Amount due and payment date | Amount due and payment date |
| First term | Months that payment buys | Months that payment buys |
| Renewal | Month it starts, term length and full bill | Month it starts, term length and full bill |
| Domain | Registration or renewal, due date and any transfer charge | What changes, what stays and each due date |
| Mailboxes, storage, price and renewal date | Mailboxes you need, any trial end date and the ongoing price | |
| Other essentials | Paid backups, licenses or services you need | The same services, leaving out extras you won’t use |
| Tax | Tax from your invoice, or a clearly marked estimate | Tax from your quote, or a clearly marked estimate |
| Cancellation and refunds | Notice deadline, fees and confirmed refund terms | Notice deadline, fees and confirmed refund terms |
| Overlap | Any extra payment while both services run | Old hosting or email you keep paying for during the move |
| Cash paid during the period | Every payment due between your dates, minus only confirmed refunds | The same, including full prepaid bills |
| Cost of the period | Service used between your dates, plus moving costs | The same method, with service after the end date set aside |
| Your work | Updates, backups and admin you already handle | Getting ready to move, testing, DNS and email work, plus ongoing tasks |
If you’ve already paid for time past your start date, list it once in that row. Don’t add it as a new payment, and don’t drop it either. It’s paid for whichever way you choose, and you may not get it back if you leave early, so check your refund terms.
Track domain and email dates separately from hosting. A free first year or a trial doesn’t tell you the later price. If you change registrars, check what the transfer payment covers so you don’t also count a renewal for the same time.
Worked example: cash paid versus the cost of 24 months
Every figure in this example is made up. Neither option is a real host or a GetSimple.net offer. These are invented USD amounts to show the method, not prices, quotes or a savings claim.
Say the comparison starts when your hosting renewal comes due and runs from month 1 through month 24. Both options meet the same needs for one site. You have no prepaid balance at the start. Each bill is due at the start of its term, with no payment plans and no refunds.
For this example only, tax is a flat 10% on every charge. Real tax rates, taxed items and payment dates can differ, so use your own invoices.
| Made-up input | Stay | Switch |
|---|---|---|
| Hosting first term | $144 for 12 months, paid in month 1 | $72 for 12 months, paid in month 1 |
| Hosting renewal | $144 for 12 months, paid in month 13 | $288 for 24 months, paid in month 13 |
| Domain | $24 a year, paid in months 1 and 13 | Same domain and payments |
| $36 a year, paid in months 1 and 13 | Same email cost and payments | |
| One extra month at the old host | $0 | $12, paid in month 1 |
| Cancellation fee and refund | $0 fee, no refund | $0 fee, no refund |
In the switch option, you keep the old service one extra month for $12. That’s a made-up input, not a promise about how any host bills or cancels.
The switch option renews in month 13, not month 2. Its $288 bill covers months 13 through 36. You pay all $288 inside the comparison period, even though only 12 of those 24 months fall within it.
Add up the cash first
| Made-up cash payments, with example tax | Stay | Switch |
|---|---|---|
| Month 1: hosting, domain, email and any overlap | $224.40 | $158.40 |
| Month 13: hosting renewal, domain and email | $224.40 | $382.80 |
| Total cash paid in months 1 to 24 | $448.80 | $541.20 |
Staying takes $92.40 less cash over the period. The switch option starts with a smaller bill but needs a bigger payment in month 13.
Then count only the service you use in those 24 months
Here, spread each prepaid hosting bill evenly across the months it buys. It’s a simple way to compare, not an accounting or tax rule. Keep cancellation fees and overlap costs in full rather than spreading them over later years.
For the switch renewal, $288 over 24 months is $12 a month. Twelve of those months fall inside the period, so count $144 of that bill for months 13 through 24.
| Made-up cost of months 1 to 24 | Stay | Switch |
|---|---|---|
| Hosting | $288.00 | $216.00 |
| Domain | $48.00 | $48.00 |
| $72.00 | $72.00 | |
| Extra month at the old host | $0.00 | $12.00 |
| Subtotal | $408.00 | $348.00 |
| Example tax at 10% | $40.80 | $34.80 |
| Total cost of the period | $448.80 | $382.80 |
Counted this way, the made-up switch option costs $66 less for these 24 months. But it still takes $92.40 more cash during them. This cost of the period isn’t everything a choice costs you, since it leaves out your time and anything past month 24, and it isn’t money you get back.
The gap between the switch option’s cash total and its cost for the period is $158.40. That’s $144 of hosting for months 25 through 36, plus $14.40 of example tax. It’s service you’ve paid for ahead of time, not money you get back. Don’t subtract it from the bill, and don’t assume you can cancel and collect it. Check the refund terms before you count any refund.
This example stops at month 24. To look further out, you’d need to add the stay option’s later bills too. It also assumes prices don’t change, both services are equal and money today is worth the same as money later.
Add the work before you decide
Price is only part of the fit. List your site files and database needs, your mailbox count and storage, the software you need and any updates your current host handles for you. A plan for one site doesn’t replace an account with several sites unless you price each site separately.
Put a value on your time only if it helps you decide. In a separate made-up check, six hours of your time at $25 an hour adds $150 to the switch option’s $382.80. That brings it to $532.80, or $84 more than staying, before counting any time spent on staying. This isn’t an invoice or a tax figure. The six hours and the hourly rate are invented, so use your own estimate and count extra work on either side.
Ask what the move includes. Copying your website, registering your domain, changing DNS and moving mailboxes are separate jobs. Don’t assume one migration quote covers all four, or that the new host will take over updates your current host handles.
If you’re moving to Simple Source, our preview guide covers moving WordPress and Joomla sites for new accounts. With a new account, we move your site for you at no extra cost, on a best-effort basis. Keep your own backup of your current site. A migration can miss things, and changes you make to the old site afterward may not be in the copy.
When a temporary preview is available, check your site there before you change DNS. Test your admin login, forms and plugins or extensions. Always check your site once it’s live. Decide where your email will run, note the old host’s cancellation deadline and keep copies of anything you need before you cancel. These checks are still yours to do, even with our best-effort migration.
Decide with both totals in front of you
You might stay, move, pick a different plan or get one more quote first. A small difference in cost may not be worth a bigger cash payment, or a move to a plan that doesn’t fit your site.
If Simple Source fits what you need, compare our plans and pricing and put the term and amounts you’d choose into your worksheet. You can also read about how our renewal prices work and our preview guide before you decide.
If you’re working from a SiteGround renewal notice, compare SiteGround renewal costs with ours and add both sets of numbers to this worksheet.
To see what our plans include, check our NVMe SSD shared hosting page for storage, RAM and LiteSpeed details. If you’re filling this in for a verified 501(c)(3), our nonprofit web hosting page explains how to get 10% off.